Ugly Maple Syrup Pie

Well guys, I’ve gone from a post here about Bright and Beautiful Recipes To Make Us Happy, to pie.  Ugly pie at that.  I’ve tortured myself over this pie post.  In fact, I was so mad at the filling for cracking and the pastry for shrinking, that I left the pie to sit for two days.  Uneaten for two whole days!  After which, I seriously got ahold of myself, and realized that this world has far bigger problems than an ugly pie.

Maple Syrup Pie via SweetRevelations

And guess what?  I make mistakes too.  And this blog is a great place to learn about them.  And from them.  I bet Ree, Nigella, and Ina have had a whole mess of ugly pies.  That doesn’t mean we’re idiots, it just means that in the kitchen, we’re…well…we’re human!

So here it is….my Ugly Maple Syrup Pie.  And friends I have to say, that this was a pretty tasty ugly pie.  The cracking and shrinking didn’t compromise the taste one bit.  As a matter of fact, I was slightly miffed at myself because we let it sit so long, because we love Maple Syrup Pie!   I seriously can’t make up my mind.  I’m mad at the pie, then I’m happy with the pie.  What gives?!

Maple Syrup Pie via SweetRevelations

I’ve written posts, like this one here, on making the perfect pastry.  And when I had the bake shop, my mom was chief pastry maker, because she’s seriously good at it.  It’s golden and tender and oh so flaky.  I’ve also made more pie fillings, than I can shake a stick at.  But some days, I’m just a complete distracted mess in the kitchen, and things don’t turn out picture perfect.  Oh man, I’ve had some doozies.  It happens to all of us.

Maple Syrup Pie via SweetRevelations

Case in point, the ugly pie.  I think I’m doing a public service here really, as I tell you and show you all of the things you shouldn’t be doing with a custard pie.  First off, you should chill the pastry well before baking.  You shouldn’t take pictures of your gorgeous pie crust, as I did here, until the pastry is nice and warm for your #PiDay2016 Instagram photo.  And then, don’t overbake that sweet Maple Syrup custard.  Because if it poofs up like a soufflé, well, you’ve gone too far.

And you’re well on your way to ugly pie.

Maple Syrup Pie via SweetRevelations

Now if mom was here, she would tell me not to fret.  “There’s nothing better than a scratch baked pie!” she always said.  Even in the bake shop, as I worried over fillings that may have oozed slightly, mom would assure me that people were going to be thrilled with their authentic, homemade pie.  And she was right.

So, ugly and all, I’m going to share my recipe for this sweet Maple Syrup Pie, using local Maple Syrup, that is the essence of spring around here when the maple sap is flowing.   It’s a custard pie with pure dark Maple Syrup, brown sugar and butter, that will satisfy any sweet tooth.  It’s a springtime favourite!  Our family all agree’s that the side of unsweetened whipped cream is essential with this dessert, to balance out the sweetness in the pie.

I hope you make this.  Because if you simply pay a little more attention than me, you’ll see how locally produced sweet Maple Syrup can bake into a beautiful, rich and smooth, sweet treat.

Just because I’m nosy and it would make me feel better, I would love to hear about your kitchen disasters in the comments below!

Happy Pie Baking friends,

Renee

xo

 

Maple Syrup Pie

  • unbaked 9 inch pastry shell
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream
  • 1/3 cup pure dark Maple Syrup
  • 1 tbsp. melted butter
  • 2 tsp flour

Unsweetened Whipped Cream

  • 1 cup of cold heavy whipping cream

Preheat oven to 350°

  1.  Whisk together the sugar, eggs and cream until well combined.  Whisk in the Maple Syrup, butter and flour.
  2. Pour filling into pastry shell and bake for 50 to 60 minutes.  Filling should still slightly jiggle in the center when moved.   Allow the pie to cool completely before serving.
  3. Whisk cream by hand or with a mixer until soft peaks form.  Serve the pie with the whipped cream.  Refrigerate any left over pie.

22 Comments

Filed under Pie

22 responses to “Ugly Maple Syrup Pie

  1. With a dollop of cream, who can tell?! I think it looks tasty!

  2. Michelle

    We put so much pressure on ourselves to be so perfect and only show perfect things. Thanks for sharing your pie with us! I think it looks delicious!

  3. I think this looks delicious! Who creates the rules anyway on what looks perfect. I think it looks amazing. You have also shown you are just human. Great post. x

  4. It’s really not ugly – it’s just brown! It’s all about the flavor to me. And it’s pretty with the whipped cream!!!

  5. Nobody is perfect and baking can never be 100% all the time. My hubbies gran who is an awesome baker and has been baking cakes since time began ( from scratch and recipes in her head) says she gets things wrong too! I always say that as long as it tastes good that’s all the matters, don’t beat yourself up about the pie looking ” ugly”. On my blog I let people know if things have gone wrong too as its all a learning curve and baking won’t be perfect all the time!

  6. I think it looks lovely … and certainly delicious!! 😀

  7. A little dusting of icing sugar usually does the trick in hiding any imperfections, however your pie certainly looks delicious to me!

  8. Kat

    For an ugly pie, it looks pretty good! I had a few kitchen fails myself last week. It’s nice to know I’m not the only one. X
    https://beanieandtalbot.wordpress.com/2016/03/18/baking-bonanza-kitchen-fails/

  9. Homeschooled Girls

    Taffy. Didn’t turn out well AT ALL. Don’t worry, youre not the only one! 🙂

  10. I’ve never made a pie from scratch, but it’s on my list of things to try. And ugly or not, I think this one might be a strong contender for my first attempt! The recipe looks SO yummy!

  11. I would definitely eat this and I have seen a lot “uglier” pies than this. Looks scrummy!

  12. It is what is inside that counts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s